In my rotation as well is MAC Smoulder, it's a great pencil to smudge out. Lets take a look at how dark it is.
MAC Kohl in Smoulder
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide on Pencil in Zero
Urban Decay 24/7 Glide on Pencil in Perversion
L-R MAC Smoulder, Urban Decay Zero, Urban Decay Perversion
All products mentioned were purchased with my own money. All comments made above are mine, with no outside influence. All photos are mine unless otherwise noted, all images not taken by me (HMU watermark) show a reference source, all rights reserved to those who own them. All links are non-affiliate links, so click away! I have no affiliation with any companies mentioned.